is there an eye of the needle gate in jerusalem

Mark 10:25 Parallel Commentaries Some scholars believe that there is this narrow gate in Jerusalem called the eye of a needle. Nov 29, 2015 - The eye of the needle mentioned in the book of Matthew was one of several gates that provided passage through the city of Jerusalem's massive walls. It was intentionally narrow and low so that travelers could only enter one-by-one and any beast of burden (e.g. It is theoretically possible that there was a "Needle Gate" or "Needle's Eye Gate" -- but Jerusalem was a fortress, and a very strong one; it took the Romans years to conquer it both during Pompey's campaigns in the first century B.C.E. Lots of commentaries say that The “Eye of the Needle” was a gate in Jerusalem, which opened after the main gate was closed at night. There was a huckster in the town who had been converted by Philip; and he heard of it, and looked for a needle with a large eye, but Peter said: Nothing is impossible with God rather bring a needle with a small eye. One of the most common explanations I've heard in church, is that Jesus is referring to a small gate or low entrance into Jerusalem, known as the Camel Gate. Re: The Eye Of The Needle There was and still exists today in Jerusalem a narrow passage between two walls of the city that is referred to as the eye of the needle. It was too... See full answer below. It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God. This gate was designed in such a way that it could be used by pedestrians but not by marauding bandits on their camels. and No you can’t crawl to get in the eye of the needle. the camel) would have to be either lightly loaded or completely unloaded. Nov 29, 2015 - The eye of the needle mentioned in the book of Matthew was one of several gates that provided passage through the city of Jerusalem's massive walls. Small doors such as this were common features of the gates of ancient cities; humans could pass through fairly easily, but large animals, such as camels, had to be unloaded and then had to kneel to get through, even then with difficulty." Years ago, a friend related a story of a gate in the wall around ancient Jerusalem called the "Eye of the Needle," or the "Needle's Eye." If the side of the city gate story were true then there would be something that that human could do to enter the kingdom. On my visit to Jerusalem (I traveled by bus and not by camel) I personally went through it and understood the picture Jesus was portraying clearly. states, "And again I say unto you, It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God." Eye of Needle Gate. That, or capitalists are totally hosed. but when you look at the different accounts of Jesus's conversation here Matthew And Luke all use a different word for the eye or the hole in the needle, and then Luke uses a completely different word from the other two for needle. However, it does not change the meaning of what he said, and the message remains the same. Thank you In the attempt to understand what Jesus means, there have been a few popular interpretations. However, that is not what Jesus was talking about. But no, Jesus reminds us that the only way into the kingdom is for God to take us there. One may see them today in Jerusalem and Damascus, where the local tour guides will call them by the term “eye of the needle,” but there are no such gates dating prior to the twelfth century A.D. Jesus is likely referring to the actual eye of a needle, something familiar to the ancient world and even us. It was purposely small for security reasons, and a camel could only go through it by stripping off any saddles or packs and crawling through on its knees. And as camels were used for transportation and carrying loads, they might pass through this narrow gate called the eye of a needle. The Jaffa Gate in the wall of Jerusalem, showing the 'Needle's Eye.' And yet it would be impossible for them to pass through unless they unload everything they carry. What many believe Jesus meant by this was that in order to enter the Holy City, camel drivers would have to remove all of their baggage to pass through and enter the gate. There was a gate that was for people only in Jerusalem called (roughly) the needle, and it was difficult to put a camel through it. Nov 3, 2018 - The eye of the needle mentioned in the book of Matthew was one of several gates that provided passage through the city of Jerusalem's massive walls. “Note: The idea of applying ‘the needle’s eye’ to small gates seems to be a modern one; there is no ancient trace of it. Next, the history and archaeology. There was never a small gate in Jerusalem which camels had to kneel to enter! One hears about a gate through the wall of Jerusalem called the “eye of the needle,” but it seems to be a spurious reference. There is a tiny gate in the walls of Jerusalem which had that sort nickname. It has been thought the reference here was to a postern door set in a gate of Jerusalem. From this article. In fact, there’s a much stronger case that such a gate with an “eye of the needle” did not exist at that time. The rich young ruler was a product of the Jewish religious system, and his self-assurance about earning his salvation was a direct … From The Straight Dope:. I lean towards the second --A Non ymous That's a very odd statement. There’s another group that favors the “Needle-Gate” theory, and they’re grounded in the same mindset that Christ originally rebuked. Kneeling under the Camel Gate. The camel is the largest animal in the Middle East, and the eye of the needle is the smallest opening we have seen. 2. In Jerusalem, there is an Eye of the Needle Gate. 19:24 "a camel to go through the eye of a needle" There has been much discussion over this phrase. "It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God." I have visited Israel, there is not now, nor ever has there been a gate called, “The Eye of the Needle.” The point Jesus was making was that just as a camel cannot go thru the eye of the needle, nor can men and women be saved by their own good works. Does anyone know exactly where in Jerusalem that is? The Lord’s object in the statement is to express human impossibility and there is no need to endeavor to soften the difficulty by taking the needle to mean anything more than the ordinary instrument. The rich young ruler was a product of the Jewish religious system, and his self-assurance about earning his salvation was a direct … The idea of the "eye of the needle" being a gate apparently had its origins in the Middle Ages. I do not know the origin of the teaching that the "Needle's Eye" refers to a small gate into Jerusalem, but this teaching is mentioned in the Hasting's Dictionary of the Bible that was published in 1901. Why would a guy excavated Nazareth know anything about Jerusalem? Legend has it that there was a small gate in the wall that surrounded Jerusalem. I have heard there is a gate in Jerusalem called The Eye of the Needle. When they closed the main gate at sunset this small gate, called the “eye of the needle” was the only way you could get in and out of the city. This was an emergency exit/entrance that was the only access at night. On the surface, this would at a minimum lead us to believe that Jesus was using an exaggerated metaphor of a camel passing through a sewing needle. Moreover, the guides have taken the term “eye of the needle” from modern commentators of the Matthew passage and not from an authentic ancient tradition. I heard somewhere that there was a small gate in the walls of the 1st century city of Jerusalem called "The Needle's Eye" through which it was very difficult for a camel to pass and that it was this gate that the biblical quote referred to originally. We will never know for sure if Jesus was thing of that gate or of an actual needle. Some theorize that the needle Jesus was speaking of was the Needle Gate, supposedly a low and narrow after-hours entrance found in the wall surrounding Jerusalem. Answer 1 of 4: Hello, I am visiting Israel in a few months time. No you can’t get on your knees. Scofield Reference Notes. Q. They had to let go in order … Only God can save us, that is why we have Ephesians 2: 8, 9. Margin eye of . Secondly, if this was a specific gate in Jerusalem, you would expect it to be referred to by name and many uh say that the name was uh the eye of a needle. "Meyers, who personally excavated the village of Nazareth where Jesus lived during a 19-year-period, says there is absolutely no evidence of an "eye of the needle" gate in Jerusalem." There are typically two ideas: 1. There is no historical evidence a gate like this called the eye of the needle existed in Jerusalem. Jaffa Gate: Interesting -- Eye of The Needle - See 1,010 traveler reviews, 416 candid photos, and great deals for Jerusalem, Israel, at Tripadvisor. It was an oriental exaggeration, in which it would be impossible for rich people to be saved! and during the Jewish Revolt of 66. The large green gate in the photo above that is located behind my friends, Roger and Linda, is a larger gate door that would be closed at night, but the little door that is open behind them is called the Eye of the Needle Gate. Some have tried to apply Jesus expression “the eye of a needle” to some sort of narrow entrance in a wall or a gateway through which a camel had to painfully crawl. It was only big enough for a human to walk through. Concerning such a gate, Hugh Nibley has made the following comment: “That’s an invention of modern-day criticism. There’s another group that favors the “Needle-Gate” theory, and they’re grounded in the same mindset that Christ originally rebuked. (Matthew 19:24) For the last two centuries it has been common teaching in Sunday School that there is a gate in Jerusalem called the eye of the needle through which a camel could not pass unless it stooped and first had all its baggage first removed. This proverb has always been intriguing. A rich man cannot get to heaven, because his money cannot buy his salvation. In Jerusalem, the "eye of the needle" gate was reportedly a small gate that opened at night after the city's main gate closed. The needle, what once was part of the wall leading into the Old City. Is it literal or figurative? The notion your Baptist friend has picked up apparently comes from a single ninth-century commentary which asserts that in first-century Jerusalem there was a gate called the Needle's Eye which a camel could only get through on its knees. No you can’t remove all your burden.